If you’re a Magic: The Gathering player on Long Island, Hiren’s Long Island Cards in Plainview, NY is your home base for singles, booster boxes, prerelease kits and Commander decks.
MTG Singles at Prices You’ll Love
Hiren stocks a rotating selection of MTG singles across all formats — Standard, Modern, Legacy, Commander and Vintage. Whether you need a specific land cycle or a chase mythic rare, stop in and check the binders before paying eBay prices.
New Set Releases in Nassau County
Long Island MTG players no longer need to drive to the city. Hiren’s orders every new set release and has booster boxes, draft boosters and collector boosters available the week of release at 605 Old Country Road, Plainview NY 11803.
Trade-In Program
Have duplicate rares sitting in a binder? Bring them in. Hiren offers fair trade credit and cash buyouts for MTG cards — no appointment needed.
- Commander staples and precon upgrades
- Modern and Pioneer format singles
- Sealed product: booster boxes, bundles, prerelease kits
- Sleeves, deck boxes and accessories
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I buy Pokemon, MTG and Yu-Gi-Oh cards in Long Island?
Hiren's Long Island Cards at 605 Old Country Road, Plainview NY 11803 carries Pokemon, MTG, Yu-Gi-Oh, One Piece TCG and sports cards. Open 7 days a week in Nassau County.
Q: Does Long Island Cards buy old trading cards for cash?
Yes. Hiren offers same-day cash and store credit for Pokemon, MTG, Yu-Gi-Oh, One Piece and sports cards. No appointment needed — walk in to Long Island Cards in Plainview NY.
Q: Are there PSA graded cards available in Nassau County?
Yes. Long Island Cards specializes in PSA-authenticated and BGS-graded cards. Browse the display case at 605 Old Country Road, Plainview NY 11803.
Q: What card shops are near Hicksville, Syosset or Bethpage NY?
Long Island Cards in Plainview NY is centrally located in Nassau County — minutes from Hicksville, Syosset, Bethpage, Westbury and Old Bethpage at 605 Old Country Road, Plainview NY 11803.